Skurvy5

Root - Better Bot Project: First Impressions

Review
Back again with another Brian’s battery review for Root, played solo using the Better Bot Project. The Better Bot Project originated as a print and play AI system to recreate the multiplayer experience of Root in a single player model.  The Project was so fantastic and well done that the designers actually incorporated the system into an official expansion for the game. 

Normally I’m extremely hesitant to use print and play variants. I find that the printing portion never turns out quite right and ends up being distracting as the quality is so poor. I’m also too cheap to actually spend money to have them professionally printed (I also that kind of defeats the purpose). But in this case the game is worth suffering through the distractions. Because It. Is. So. Good. 

For those unfamiliar with Root: Root is an extremely asymmetrical war game hidden under beautiful, lovable, phenomenal art. The art belies the true nature of the game - it can often be cutthroat and tense; each round is suspenseful. The base game contains 4 factions, all of whom play almost like their own board game. (There are multiple expansion factions for this game but I was only able to acquire the base game)

The Marquis de Cats use euro-style engine building to maintain control of the woodlands while the Eyrie uses action programming in their bid to win the forest. The Rebel Woodland Alliance uses Guerilla warfare and ambushes to win support while the Vagabond feels like Link from the Zelda games going on his own adventure amongst it all. 

Despite how different each factions play, all players each have the same goal: to earn 30 victory points and win control of the woodland. 

Let’s pounce on in to the review:

Component quality (+++): Wow. Just wow. Look at those stunningly cute wooden Meeples. Gaze in wonder at the beautiful art in the cards and on the game board and player boards. The card quality is phenomenal. The cardboard for the tokens is excellent. No complaints at all about the components. 

Rulebook (+): The rule book is great. It’s done in that newer style where you have a learn to play booklet as well as a rules almanac. This style is great because once you become more familiar with the game you only need to reference The Law of Root and not mess around with the learn to play portions. The paper used for the rulebook is great and the art and examples are fantastic. 

Box size (-): As much as I love this game I am really annoyed with the size of the box. It’s JUST barely big enough to hold everything and I think that the included insert is worse than just using the box. I actually took my insert out and decided to store the game without it. For all the greatness of this game this is a minor quibble. 

Faction Asymmetry (+++): The diversity of the factions is incredible. It really feels like they took 4 unique games and mashed them together. And yet it still feels balanced. I can’t imagine how much fun this would be multiplayer because it’s so great solo. 

Multi-Use Cards (+++): Despite the incredibly varied play styles all factions utilize a common shared resource: cards. Cards are a precious resource and you never feel like you have enough of them. The cards also have multiple uses that lead to agonizing decisions. Do you use that card to craft a powerful ability? Do you save it to use during combat? Or do you spend it for a faction ability? Delicious decision making. 

Better Bot Project (++): The Project is a stroke of genius. It hits the trifecta of AI abilities: 1. Easy to run. 2. Realistically simulates a human player 3. Challenging. Very well done. 

Root is phenomenal. I can’t wait to add some of the expansion factions in the future. I also look forward to the day when I can play it multiplayer. An excellent game with an excellent print and play variant. 

4 points by Skurvy5 - updated 53 days ago | 49 comments | report | subscribe

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Ohhhh, I totally forgot to comment on your descriptions of the factions, which I loved.  As soon as I saw how the Vagabond played I was thinking, this is like a mini version of Zelda.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Thanks! The little sword and boots definitely take me back to Zelda on the SNES. 

philryuh Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

That's a lot of pluses I've never seen before on your other reviews! Must have great prospects to climb its way to the top of your top 5?

Great write-up and you hit on points that I really like about Root but wouldn't have been able to express. I've yet to play as the Vagabond but want to. I used to be a bit intimidated about trying them out but after watching a video, their actions made a lot more sense. Hoping to get in a solo game this week after getting into the rules and printing out better bots. It's also one of my most photogenic games (alongside Viticulture) and I made an ad image out of it to capture the essence of BGA (not sure if it's smart of me to use WA to represent us though haha)


Marshwiggle92 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

I saw this on Twitter. I love it. 

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

It’s a wonderfully designed little picture. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Oh yeah, Viticulture is so photogenic.  I can't wait, I think I'm going to get a solo play (of Root) in tonight.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

A friend asked for my Top 5 last night and Root featured at #5. 

Also we are absolutely the Alliance. Upstart community tried of the old fashioned oppressors. 

What parts did I get that you wouldn’t have been able to?

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

I’ve always had cursory interest in those Roman themed ones. But maybe?

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

We could also accuse Phil and Trent of being the Riverfolk as they peddle their wares (giveaways) to draw new people to the site.

philryuh Supporter53 days ago | 1 point[-]

Can't argue with that one lol

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

True, true. Lol. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Haha, nice.  Or are we the Lizard Cult, reaching out to those who feel discarded by the bigger site?

Also, awesome it's already in your top 5.  I do hope you get to play it multiplayer at some point, because the table talk aspect of the game is so fun.

philryuh Supporter55 days ago | 1 point[-]

Hmm.. potential BGA mascot inspiration.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Mmm yeah. I’m really looking forward to it. 

philryuh Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Hmmm good question. There are loads of things I love about Root and one of its surprising qualities is that it's quite... "minimal" or "efficient". There aren't tons of components in the game in comparison to how complex the gameplay is, and it goes hand in hand with your point about the multi-use cards.

Another aspect of Root that I really like is that you should almost always be concerned about even the simplest action performed by another player. I love that a simple act of a player putting down a piece of cardboard (e.g. sympathy token) has players immediately thinking about how they should respond to the change in board state.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Gotcha. It’s such a delicious game. I think it’ll be even better multiplayer. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

I used the Mechanical Marquise to teach my daughter the Eyrie.  It's a great way for me to introduce even my 7 year old to the different factions of the game.  I'm excited to practice the Eyrie with her again and then maybe teacher her the Woodland Alliance after that.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Great! Did you use the official mechanical marquis or the better bot one?

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Better Bot.  Everything I’ve seen makes me think it is vastly superior.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Definitely feels that way in my experience. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Were you able to learn how to run the Automated Alliance just with the board and rules?  I watched videos to learn how to run the Marquise and Eyrie.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

I think I’m still making mistakes with a few of the minor rules. And I definitely had to watch tons of learn to play videos with the bots. It wasn’t the easiest thing to learn. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Who did you play as?  What was the best way for you to learn how to run the bots?

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Played as Marquis twice (1-1) and Rebel Alliance (0-1). 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Which did you like better?

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

I liked the Rebel Alliance better. As a player I don’t take enough risks to continually be building like the Cats need to do. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Mmm gotya.  I feel like probably the Marquise are the lowest on what people like to play.  I try to enjoy them for what they are when I play multiplayer in case I need to run them.  But I also know the Duchy is supposed to be a faction that can replace the Marquise.

The Woodland Alliance has ebbed and flowed for me.  Sometimes I really like them, sometimes I don't.

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Also, I think it's a huge testament to a game when you can lose a lot and still have an awesome time.  I really like the Lizard Cult, but they are pretty much universally seen as the most difficult to play and win with.  I think I've played them 4 times and I'm 1-3 with them.  But I still love playing them.

Marshwiggle92 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Rebel alliance?? I assume that you call it that because of your heavy star wars influence. 

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Of course. Also they fee very similar to the rebel alliance 

Marshwiggle92 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

That's what I assumed. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Awesome.  Did you run the WA bot?  How was it?  I’ve yet to run them as a bot.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

It was good. Not too difficult to manage. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Great!  I’m thinking of running the Marquise and Alliance tonight and play as the Duchy.

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Great review.  I'm so glad you loved it.  Hopefully my baby will be sleep trained up soon and we can play on TTS.

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Amen!

Marshwiggle92 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

You make me so excited. I can barely wait. How do you think it will stack up with some of your favorites? Also, are you playing with all of the bots at once? 

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

I’ve played with 2 bots and myself. I haven’t added the Vagabond faction yet. 

Marshwiggle92 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Does the vagabond look like it will be more complex to run? 

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Not necessarily. I just was trying the recommended combos first. I think I’ll try a 4 player game today. 

Marshwiggle92 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

Sounds fun. 

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]


Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]


philryuh Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

I love spreading around those sympathy tokens.

Marshwiggle92 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

These pieces are so photogenic. 

sdirrane Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

It has to be my favorite game to take and share photos of.

Marshwiggle92 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

I can imagine. 

Skurvy5 Supporter56 days ago | 1 point[-]

They really are. Absolutely gorgeous. 

Linked Games

Root